Discovering WWOOFing Alternatives: Exploring Cultural Exchange and Community Engagement

Home ยป Discovering WWOOFing Alternatives: Exploring Cultural Exchange and Community Engagement

Posted By:

Discovering WWOOFing Alternatives: Exploring Cultural Exchange and Community Engagement

WWOOF, which stands for World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms, is an organization that facilitates a unique form of cultural and educational exchange. WWOOF connects individuals, often from urban areas, with local farmers in various communities around the world. The primary goal of WWOOF is to promote sustainable agriculture practices while fostering a deeper understanding and appreciation for different cultures and lifestyles.

One of the key aspects of WWOOF is its emphasis on recognizing and supporting farmers in the economy. Farmers play a vital role in our society, providing us with essential food and resources. However, their contributions often go unnoticed or underappreciated. WWOOF aims to bridge this gap by creating opportunities for urban individuals to engage directly with farmers, learn about their work, and provide them with much-needed moral support and motivation.

Through WWOOF, participants have the chance to immerse themselves in the world of farming, gaining hands-on experience and expanding their knowledge of organic practices. This experience extends beyond just working on the farm, as it encourages cultural exchange and the sharing of values and traditions between volunteers and farmers.

By participating in WWOOF, individuals can break free from their urban routines and step into a new world of culture and experience. They have the opportunity to meet new people, build meaningful connections, and gain a fresh perspective on sustainable living. Moreover, WWOOF allows urban dwellers to develop a greater appreciation for the rural communities that often go unnoticed, creating awareness of the vital role farmers play in our society.

In the following sections of this article, we will explore various alternatives to WWOOFing, providing insights into different programs and initiatives that offer similar opportunities for cultural exchange and community engagement. These alternatives not only widen the scope of experiences available to individuals but also contribute to the overall goal of empowering farmers and fostering a stronger bond between urban and rural communities.

Understanding WWOOFing: A Unique Cultural Exchange Program

WWOOFing, or World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms, is a distinctive cultural exchange program that connects individuals who are interested in sustainable agriculture with organic farmers around the world. The core principle of WWOOFing is to provide a platform for volunteers, known as WWOOFers, to contribute their time and skills to participating farms in exchange for food, accommodation, and the opportunity to learn about organic farming practices.

One of the primary benefits of WWOOFing is the mutual advantage it brings to both volunteers and farmers. For volunteers, WWOOFing offers a chance to step out of their comfort zones, immerse themselves in rural environments, and gain practical knowledge about organic farming techniques. WWOOFers can develop new skills related to farming, such as planting, harvesting, and animal care, while also learning about sustainable practices that can be applied in their own lives.

WWOOFing also provides volunteers with the opportunity to experience a different way of life and engage in cultural exchange. By living and working alongside local farmers, WWOOFers can learn about their host community’s traditions, customs, and values. This cross-cultural understanding helps to break down barriers and foster empathy and respect between people from diverse backgrounds.

For farmers, WWOOFing brings numerous benefits as well. Firstly, WWOOFers provide much-needed assistance with farm work, which can be labor-intensive, especially during busy seasons. Volunteers can help with tasks such as planting, weeding, harvesting, and maintaining the farm’s infrastructure. This support lightens the workload for farmers, allowing them to focus on other aspects of their operations.

Additionally, WWOOFing enables farmers to share their knowledge and expertise with volunteers. They can pass on valuable skills related to organic farming methods, ecological practices, and sustainable agriculture. This exchange of information not only benefits the WWOOFers but also promotes the spread of environmentally friendly farming techniques and helps farmers expand their networks.

Furthermore, the cultural exchange aspect of WWOOFing is invaluable for farmers. By hosting volunteers from different parts of the world, farmers can share their way of life, traditions, and local customs. This interaction not only enriches the WWOOFers’ understanding of different cultures but also allows farmers to gain insights into global perspectives and ideas. It broadens their horizons and strengthens the sense of community and interconnectedness among farmers worldwide.

In summary, WWOOFing serves as a unique cultural exchange program that benefits both volunteers and farmers. It provides volunteers with hands-on learning experiences, exposure to sustainable farming practices, and the chance to engage in cross-cultural understanding. For farmers, WWOOFing brings assistance with farm work, opportunities to share knowledge, and the enrichment of hosting individuals from diverse backgrounds. Through WWOOFing, the bonds between urban and rural communities are strengthened, and a deeper appreciation for sustainable agriculture and cultural diversity is fostered.

The Need for WWOOFing Alternatives

While WWOOFing offers a valuable cultural exchange experience, it is important to recognize that it may not be suitable for everyone or fulfill all the needs and preferences of individuals seeking such opportunities. Exploring alternatives to WWOOFing can address some of the limitations and challenges associated with the program, while still providing enriching cultural exchange experiences.

One limitation of WWOOFing as a sole option for cultural exchange is its focus primarily on organic farming. While this is a valuable aspect, individuals interested in other areas of community development, environmental conservation, or cultural immersion may find WWOOFing too specialized for their interests. WWOOFing alternatives allow individuals to explore a wider range of activities and engage with different communities beyond organic farming.

Participating in WWOOFing programs can also present challenges for volunteers. Language barriers, limited access to modern amenities, and geographical restrictions can sometimes create difficulties for individuals seeking a meaningful cultural exchange experience. Additionally, the commitment and duration required for WWOOFing programs may not align with everyone’s schedules or availability. Alternatives to WWOOFing can offer more flexibility in terms of time commitment and the types of activities involved.

Introducing the concept of WWOOFing alternatives opens up possibilities for individuals to engage in diverse forms of cultural exchange and community engagement. These alternatives can include programs that focus on sustainable agriculture, such as permaculture initiatives or agroforestry projects. They can also encompass broader community development efforts, such as educational programs, social entrepreneurship, or eco-tourism initiatives that promote cultural exchange while addressing local challenges.

The potential benefits of WWOOFing alternatives are numerous. Firstly, individuals have the opportunity to explore their specific areas of interest within the realm of community engagement and cultural exchange. By diversifying the available options, alternatives cater to a broader range of passions and skills, allowing participants to make meaningful contributions aligned with their individual strengths and aspirations.

Furthermore, alternatives to WWOOFing can provide greater flexibility in terms of location and duration. Participants can choose programs that suit their preferences and availability, whether it be short-term projects in their local communities or longer-term engagements in different regions of the world. This flexibility allows for a more personalized experience and can accommodate individuals who may have constraints on their time or travel capabilities.

Lastly, WWOOFing alternatives contribute to the overall goal of fostering cultural understanding and appreciation. By engaging in different community-based initiatives, participants have the opportunity to connect with local residents, learn about their customs and traditions, and contribute to their development in meaningful ways. This broader scope of alternatives promotes a holistic understanding of diverse cultures, addressing social, economic, and environmental aspects beyond the realm of organic farming alone.

In conclusion, while WWOOFing is a valuable program for cultural exchange, exploring alternatives can address limitations, challenges, and individual preferences. These alternatives provide a wider range of activities, flexibility, and opportunities for community engagement. By embracing and participating in these alternatives, individuals can still experience the transformative power of cultural exchange while making meaningful contributions to communities and fostering a greater understanding and appreciation of diverse cultures.

WWOOFing Alternatives: Connecting People and Values

In addition to WWOOFing, there are several alternative programs and initiatives that offer unique avenues for cultural exchange, sustainable agriculture, and community development. These alternatives broaden the opportunities for individuals to connect with different communities and engage in meaningful activities beyond traditional farming experiences.

  1. Sustainable Agriculture Programs: These programs focus on sustainable farming practices and ecological conservation. They offer participants the chance to learn about organic farming, permaculture, agroforestry, and regenerative agriculture. Such initiatives often include hands-on activities like planting and harvesting, as well as workshops on sustainable farming techniques.
  2. Community-Based Development Projects: These projects combine cultural exchange with community development efforts. They aim to empower local communities through initiatives such as educational programs, infrastructure development, women’s empowerment projects, or healthcare initiatives. Participants can actively contribute to these projects while immersing themselves in the local culture and values.
  3. Environmental Conservation and Ecotourism Initiatives: These alternatives promote sustainable environmental practices while fostering cultural exchange. Participants can engage in activities like wildlife conservation, reforestation, marine conservation, or eco-tourism projects. They have the opportunity to work with local communities, learn about indigenous knowledge, and contribute to the preservation of natural resources.
  4. Social Entrepreneurship Programs: These programs combine business innovation with social impact. Participants can work with local entrepreneurs and organizations to develop sustainable solutions for community challenges. They can engage in activities such as developing social enterprises, supporting fair trade initiatives, or implementing projects that promote sustainable livelihoods and economic empowerment.
  5. Cultural Immersion Experiences: These alternatives focus on providing immersive cultural experiences beyond farming activities. Participants can engage in language immersion programs, art and craft workshops, traditional cooking classes, music and dance exchanges, or cultural heritage preservation initiatives. These experiences allow individuals to deeply engage with local customs, traditions, and values.
  6. Exchange Programs with Indigenous Communities: These programs facilitate cultural exchange with indigenous communities, promoting mutual learning and appreciation. Participants can live with indigenous groups, learn about their unique cultures, and support community-led initiatives that aim to preserve indigenous knowledge, traditional practices, and sustainable ways of life.

These WWOOFing alternatives offer a wide range of opportunities for individuals to connect with communities, learn from diverse cultures, and contribute to sustainable practices and community development. They provide participants with a chance to align their values and interests with meaningful activities, fostering a deeper understanding of global challenges and promoting a more interconnected and sustainable world.

Volunteerism: Making a Difference in Local Communities

Volunteerism plays a crucial role in supporting local farmers and communities, creating a positive impact on both sustainable agriculture and the overall well-being of rural areas. By offering their time, skills, and dedication, volunteers contribute to the development and resilience of farming communities while fostering a sense of empowerment and solidarity. Here, we will explore the importance of volunteering in supporting local farmers and communities, discuss various volunteering opportunities related to farming and sustainable practices, and highlight success stories of volunteers positively impacting the lives of farmers.

Importance of Volunteering:

  • Volunteers provide valuable support to farmers by assisting with labor-intensive tasks, helping to reduce workloads during busy seasons, and enabling farmers to focus on other critical aspects of their operations.
  • Through volunteering, individuals actively contribute to the sustainability and resilience of local food systems, promoting organic practices, ecological conservation, and community-based initiatives.
  • Volunteerism fosters a sense of community engagement and shared responsibility, empowering individuals to make a tangible difference in the lives of farmers and the overall well-being of rural areas.

Volunteering Opportunities:

  • Farm Work: Volunteers can engage in a variety of farming activities, including planting, harvesting, weeding, soil preparation, and tending to livestock. These hands-on experiences provide practical knowledge about sustainable farming practices.
  • Education and Awareness: Volunteers can participate in educational programs aimed at raising awareness about sustainable agriculture, nutrition, and food security. They can organize workshops, demonstrations, and training sessions for farmers and community members.
  • Environmental Conservation: Volunteering can involve activities such as reforestation, soil conservation, water management, and biodiversity preservation. These efforts contribute to the long-term sustainability of farming ecosystems.
  • Community Development: Volunteers can support community development initiatives by assisting with infrastructure projects, implementing social programs, promoting entrepreneurship, or working on initiatives that enhance the quality of life in rural areas.

Success Stories:

  • Volunteers have helped farmers transition to organic farming practices, reducing the use of harmful chemicals and improving the quality of produce.
  • Through educational programs led by volunteers, farmers have gained knowledge about sustainable techniques, resulting in increased crop yields and improved farm profitability.
  • Volunteer-led initiatives have facilitated the establishment of farmer cooperatives, enhancing market access, and enabling farmers to negotiate fair prices for their products.
  • Volunteers have played a significant role in promoting sustainable agriculture and raising awareness about environmental issues, leading to increased adoption of eco-friendly practices by farmers.

These success stories illustrate how volunteering can create transformative change in the lives of farmers and the communities they serve. By dedicating their time and skills, volunteers contribute to the sustainability of farming practices, support local economies, and foster a sense of unity between urban and rural areas. Through their efforts, volunteers not only make a difference in the lives of farmers but also inspire others to actively engage in creating a more sustainable and equitable food system.

Experiencing the World: Benefits of International Cultural Exchange

International cultural exchange offers individuals numerous advantages, from personal growth and development to increased intercultural understanding and global awareness. By engaging in cross-cultural experiences, individuals can broaden their horizons, challenge their perspectives, and gain a deeper appreciation for diverse cultures. In this section, we will discuss the advantages of international cultural exchange, highlight its impact on personal growth and development, and share statistics and studies that showcase its transformative power.

Advantages of International Cultural Exchange:

  • Increased Intercultural Understanding: Cultural exchange allows individuals to interact with people from different backgrounds, fostering empathy, respect, and a deeper understanding of diverse perspectives, values, and traditions.
  • Global Awareness: Engaging with other cultures expands individuals’ knowledge of global issues, challenges, and opportunities. It helps develop a sense of interconnectedness and a broader perspective on social, economic, and environmental concerns.
  • Language Acquisition: Immersion in a different culture provides an ideal environment for learning and practicing new languages, enhancing communication skills and facilitating meaningful connections.
  • Personal Enrichment: International cultural exchange offers the opportunity for personal enrichment through exposure to art, music, dance, cuisine, and other aspects of diverse cultures. It opens doors to new experiences and a deeper appreciation for cultural diversity.

Impact on Personal Growth and Development:

  • Self-Reflection and Identity: Cross-cultural experiences encourage individuals to reflect on their own beliefs, values, and identity. They gain a greater understanding of themselves in relation to others, fostering personal growth and self-awareness.
  • Adaptability and Flexibility: Living in a different cultural context challenges individuals to adapt to new environments, customs, and ways of life. This develops resilience, flexibility, and the ability to thrive in diverse situations.
  • Global Citizenship: International cultural exchange cultivates a sense of global citizenship, promoting active engagement in global issues, social responsibility, and a commitment to creating a more inclusive and equitable world.
  • Expanded Worldview: Exposure to different cultures expands individuals’ worldview, challenging stereotypes and fostering a more nuanced understanding of complex global dynamics. It helps individuals think critically and approach the world with an open mind.

Transformative Power of Cultural Exchange:

  • Studies have shown that cultural exchange experiences contribute to increased intercultural competence, empathy, and tolerance.
  • According to research, individuals who engage in cultural exchange are more likely to possess skills and attributes desired by employers, such as adaptability, communication, and problem-solving abilities.
  • A survey conducted by the Institute for International Education found that 97% of students who participated in study abroad programs reported increased self-confidence and improved academic performance.
  • The Erasmus Impact Study revealed that students who engaged in international exchange programs experienced higher employability rates and greater long-term career success.

These statistics and studies highlight the transformative power of cultural exchange on individuals’ personal growth, intercultural understanding, and global perspectives. By immersing themselves in different cultures, individuals gain valuable skills, expand their worldview, and become more effective global citizens. International cultural exchange fosters connections, promotes mutual respect, and paves the way for a more inclusive and interconnected world.

Becoming a Host: Opening Doors and Embracing Diversity

Becoming a host for visitors and foreign farmers is an enriching experience that allows individuals to open their homes and embrace diversity. Hosting provides an opportunity to engage in cross-cultural exchange, foster mutual learning, and create lasting connections. In this section, we will explain the process of becoming a host, discuss the benefits for hosts in terms of cultural enrichment and mutual learning, and provide tips on creating a welcoming environment for guests.

Process of Becoming a Host:

  • Research and Preparation: Start by familiarizing yourself with organizations that facilitate cultural exchange programs, such as WWOOF or local community-based initiatives. Understand their requirements and guidelines for hosts.
  • Registration and Screening: Complete the host registration process, which may involve providing information about your farm, accommodation availability, and the activities you offer. Hosts are often screened to ensure a safe and suitable environment for guests.
  • Communication and Agreement: Once approved, communicate with potential guests to discuss expectations, duration of stay, and any specific requirements. Establish clear agreements regarding accommodation, meals, work hours, and cultural exchange activities.

Benefits for Hosts:

  • Cultural Enrichment: Hosting visitors and foreign farmers allows hosts to gain insights into different cultures, traditions, and perspectives. It broadens their horizons and deepens their understanding of global diversity.
  • Mutual Learning: Hosting creates a platform for the exchange of knowledge, experiences, and skills. Hosts can share their expertise in farming practices, local traditions, and sustainable living, while also learning from the unique perspectives and practices brought by their guests.
  • Building Connections: Hosting cultivates meaningful connections and friendships. It provides an opportunity to form long-lasting relationships with people from diverse backgrounds, fostering a global network of like-minded individuals.

Tips for Creating a Welcoming Environment:

  • Open Communication: Establish open and clear lines of communication with your guests, ensuring they feel comfortable sharing their needs, concerns, and expectations.
  • Cultural Sensitivity: Respect and appreciate the cultural differences of your guests. Be open-minded, tolerant, and willing to learn from their practices and traditions.
  • Orientation and Guidance: Provide your guests with a comprehensive orientation of your farm, its surroundings, and any safety guidelines. Offer guidance on farm activities, cultural practices, and local customs.
  • Inclusion and Participation: Encourage your guests to actively participate in farm activities, cultural events, and community engagements. Make them feel like valued members of the household and the broader community.
  • Shared Experiences: Plan activities that promote interaction and cultural exchange, such as shared meals, storytelling sessions, or local excursions. Encourage dialogue and create opportunities for meaningful connections.

By becoming a host, individuals have the opportunity to create a welcoming and inclusive environment for visitors and foreign farmers. Hosting not only enriches the lives of hosts through cultural exchange and mutual learning but also contributes to the overall mission of fostering understanding, appreciation, and solidarity among people from diverse backgrounds.

Global Reach: WWOOFing Beyond Borders

WWOOFing extends its reach beyond borders, making it a truly global movement that leaves a significant impact on individuals, communities, and sustainable agriculture worldwide. In this section, we will highlight the international presence of WWOOF and its global impact, discuss the benefits of engaging with WWOOFing programs worldwide, and provide examples of WWOOFing experiences in different countries and regions.

International Presence and Global Impact:

  • WWOOF operates in numerous countries, spanning across six continents, offering opportunities for cultural exchange, sustainable agriculture, and community engagement on a global scale.
  • WWOOF’s presence in diverse countries enables individuals to experience a wide range of farming practices, ecosystems, and cultural traditions, fostering a deeper understanding of the global challenges and solutions related to sustainable agriculture.
  • The global impact of WWOOFing is significant, as it supports local farmers by providing them with additional labor, promoting organic farming practices, and contributing to the sustainability of local food systems.

Benefits of Engaging with WWOOFing Programs Worldwide:

  • Cultural Exchange: Engaging with WWOOFing programs worldwide allows individuals to immerse themselves in different cultures, languages, and traditions. It promotes intercultural understanding, empathy, and appreciation for the diversity of human experiences.
  • Learning Opportunities: WWOOFing programs in various countries offer unique learning opportunities, allowing participants to acquire knowledge about different agricultural techniques, ecological systems, and local customs. It broadens their understanding of sustainable farming practices in different contexts.
  • Personal Growth and Global Citizenship: WWOOFing globally fosters personal growth, self-awareness, and the development of global citizenship. It challenges individuals to adapt to new environments, overcome cultural barriers, and engage with global issues, promoting a sense of responsibility towards creating a more sustainable and equitable world.

Examples of WWOOFing Experiences in Different Countries and Regions:

  • In Italy, WWOOFers can engage in traditional vineyard work, olive harvesting, and learn about organic winemaking practices.
  • In Thailand, WWOOFing opportunities may include rice farming, organic vegetable cultivation, and exploring traditional Thai agriculture techniques.
  • New Zealand offers diverse WWOOFing experiences, such as working on dairy farms, permaculture projects, or participating in sustainable forestry practices.
  • In Costa Rica, WWOOFers can contribute to organic coffee farming, tropical fruit production, and engage in agroforestry initiatives.

These examples represent just a fraction of the wide array of WWOOFing experiences available worldwide. Each country and region brings its unique farming practices, cultural heritage, and environmental contexts, providing participants with rich and diverse experiences. WWOOFing globally connects individuals to the global community of farmers, enabling cross-cultural learning, sustainable agriculture promotion, and the forging of lifelong connections across borders.

Tips for a Meaningful WWOOFing Experience

Participating in WWOOFing or its alternatives can be a transformative and rewarding experience. To make the most of your journey, it is essential to approach it with careful planning, preparation, and an open mindset. In this section, we will provide practical advice for individuals planning to engage in WWOOFing or similar programs. We will offer tips on selecting the right program, preparing for the experience, and setting expectations. Additionally, we will emphasize the importance of cultural sensitivity and open-mindedness during the exchange.

Selecting the Right Program:

  • Research and Review: Thoroughly research and review different WWOOFing programs or alternatives. Consider factors such as the program’s mission, values, host reviews, available activities, and locations to find the best fit for your interests and goals.
  • Read Host Profiles Carefully: Pay attention to the details provided by hosts, including their farming practices, accommodation, and expectations from volunteers. This will help you understand if the program aligns with your skills, interests, and comfort level.
  • Seek Recommendations: Reach out to fellow WWOOFers or individuals who have participated in similar programs to gather insights, recommendations, and first-hand experiences.

Preparing for the Experience:

  • Learn about the Local Culture: Familiarize yourself with the local culture, customs, and traditions of the region you will be visiting. Gain basic knowledge of the language spoken in the area to facilitate communication.
  • Pack Appropriately: Pack essentials such as appropriate clothing for farm work, comfortable footwear, sunscreen, insect repellent, and any specific tools or equipment requested by the program.
  • Develop Basic Farming Skills: If you have limited farming experience, consider acquiring some basic skills before starting your WWOOFing journey. This may include learning about organic farming practices, gardening, or livestock care.

Setting Expectations:

  • Understand the Commitment: Familiarize yourself with the duration, work hours, and expectations of the program. Be prepared for physically demanding work and understand that farming activities may vary depending on the season and needs of the host.
  • Embrace Flexibility: Remain flexible and adaptable as situations may change. Be open to new experiences, different ways of doing things, and unexpected challenges that may arise during your WWOOFing journey.
  • Realistic Expectations: Set realistic expectations about the level of cultural exchange, your role on the farm, and the impact you can make. Remember that your primary purpose is to learn, contribute, and engage in meaningful exchange rather than seeking personal gain or instant transformation.

Cultural Sensitivity and Open-Mindedness:

  • Respect Local Customs: Show respect for the local customs, traditions, and way of life. Be open to learning and participating in cultural activities offered by the host and community.
  • Communicate and Ask Questions: Engage in open and respectful communication with your hosts and fellow volunteers. Ask questions, seek clarification, and be willing to learn from their knowledge and experiences.
  • Embrace Differences: Embrace cultural diversity and value the differences you encounter. Appreciate the opportunity to broaden your worldview and challenge your own assumptions.

By following these tips, you can enhance your WWOOFing experience and maximize the benefits of cultural exchange and personal growth. Remember to approach your journey with an open mind, embrace new experiences, and foster a spirit of respect, curiosity, and understanding.

Conclusion: Embracing Cultural Connections

WWOOFing alternatives provide individuals with unique opportunities for cultural exchange, personal growth, and community engagement. By participating in these programs, individuals can broaden their horizons, learn about sustainable practices, and forge meaningful connections with diverse communities. In this concluding section, we will summarize the benefits and impact of WWOOFing alternatives, encourage readers to explore different avenues for cultural exchange, and emphasize the importance of recognizing and valuing farmers in our society.

WWOOFing alternatives offer a range of benefits. They promote cultural understanding, allowing individuals to immerse themselves in different cultures, traditions, and ways of life. Through engagement in sustainable agriculture and community development initiatives, participants contribute to the well-being of local communities and foster a sense of global citizenship. These experiences facilitate personal growth, expand knowledge, and develop skills that are valuable in today’s interconnected world.

It is essential to explore different avenues for cultural exchange beyond traditional WWOOFing. Look for programs and initiatives that align with your interests and values, whether it be sustainable agriculture projects, community-based development initiatives, or cultural immersion experiences. Embrace the diversity of experiences available and engage with different communities to expand your understanding of the world and foster connections that transcend borders.

Moreover, it is crucial to recognize and value the essential role that farmers play in our society. They provide us with food, contribute to the local and global economy, and promote sustainable practices. By participating in WWOOFing or its alternatives, individuals have the opportunity to actively support farmers, learn from their expertise, and raise awareness about the importance of sustainable agriculture. Let us acknowledge and appreciate their hard work, dedication, and the valuable knowledge they possess.

WWOOFing alternatives offer a gateway to cultural exchange, personal growth, and community engagement. By embracing these opportunities, individuals can enrich their lives, develop a deeper understanding of diverse cultures, and contribute to the sustainability of local communities. Let us embrace cultural connections, explore the world with an open mind, and foster a global community that values and supports farmers as they continue to play a vital role in shaping our future.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *